12503 N Small Road Hayward, WI 54843

$525,000
Active
estimated monthly payment
2 Beds  |  1 Baths  |  1,344 Sq Ft  |  Single Family  |  MLS # 1600430
  • Meticulous 1344 sq ft, 2 bedroom home with sunroom
    Meticulous 1344 sq ft, 2 bedroom home with sunroom/3rd bedroom and unfinished walkout on Nelson Lake.
  • 100 ft of lakefront with low elevation to the wate
    100 ft of lakefront with low elevation to the water.
  • 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843 Listing Photo  3
  • 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843 Listing Photo  4
  • 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843 Listing Photo  5
  • 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843 Listing Photo  6
  • 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843 Listing Photo  7
  • 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843 Listing Photo  8
  • Open water views and islands throughout the flowag
    Open water views and islands throughout the flowage for excellent fishing and full recreation.
  • Roll in dock is included plus space for boat lift.
    Roll in dock is included plus space for boat lift.
  • Newer shed for lake toys, rafts, and vests for eas
    Newer shed for lake toys, rafts, and vests for easy access to the lake.
  • Deck access right up to the main level of home.
    Deck access right up to the main level of home.
  • Tuck under garage is great for boat storage, lake
    Tuck under garage is great for boat storage, lake toys, or side by side.
  • Great curb appeal with the stone accent wall and b
    Great curb appeal with the stone accent wall and beautiful deck overlooking the lake.
  • Unfinished walkout basement offers opportunity for
    Unfinished walkout basement offers opportunity for extra living room, bedroom, and 2nd bath.
  • Gentle slope for those who prefer to enter from th
    Gentle slope for those who prefer to enter from the back door.
  • Inviting and open floor plan with wood burning fir
    Inviting and open floor plan with wood burning fireplace, generous size living room and kitchen with access into the sunroom/3rd bedroom.
  • Private views overlooking the backyard. Master bed
    Private views overlooking the backyard. Master bedroom is located straight back.
  • Furniture is optional throughout the home.
    Furniture is optional throughout the home.
  • 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843 Listing Photo  20
  • Sunroom is being used as a 3rd bedroom with beauti
    Sunroom is being used as a 3rd bedroom with beautiful lake views.
  • Sunroom/3rd bedroom
    Sunroom/3rd bedroom
  • Nice space in the kitchen to prepare meals while e
    Nice space in the kitchen to prepare meals while enjoying friends and family.
  • Plenty of cabinet and counter space. Most all kitc
    Plenty of cabinet and counter space. Most all kitchen items are included in the sale.
  • Enjoy the lake views while cleaning up or making b
    Enjoy the lake views while cleaning up or making breakfast.
  • The dining room leads to a freshly stained deck an
    The dining room leads to a freshly stained deck and fills the room with natural light.
  • Tend the BBQ while enjoying a cocktail on the expa
    Tend the BBQ while enjoying a cocktail on the expansive deck while taking in the gorgeous views.
  • 12503 N Small Road, Hayward, WI 54843 Listing Photo  28
  • Main floor master bedroom with ensuite walkthrough
    Main floor master bedroom with ensuite walkthrough bath and large closet.
  • Window of master bedroom offers private backyard v
    Window of master bedroom offers private backyard views
  • Main floor full bathroom has separate shower and s
    Main floor full bathroom has separate shower and soaking tub. Leads into the laundry room and master bedroom.
  • Bright and spacious area to get ready for the day.
    Bright and spacious area to get ready for the day.
  • Main Floor Laundry room to include electric panel,
    Main Floor Laundry room to include electric panel, broom closet, and water heater. W/D are optional for purchase.
  • Large main floor second bedroom is off of the livi
    Large main floor second bedroom is off of the living room and sunroom/3rd bedroom.
  • Large open basement has plenty of space for a walk
    Large open basement has plenty of space for a walkout living room, 3rd bedroom, and plumbed for 2nd bath. Space also includes the tuck under garage.
  • Great supporting beams and poured concrete walls a
    Great supporting beams and poured concrete walls are ready to finish however you desire.

About The Listing

Waterfront Living with Room to Grow! Enjoy year-round lake living in this inviting 2-bedroom home with a den/optional 3rd bedroom, offering the perfect blend of comfort, recreation, and future potential. The 1344 sq. ft. main floor features an open-concept kitchen and living area, complete with a cozy wood burning fireplace—ideal for gathering and relaxing. Convenient laundry room on main as well. Step out from the dining area onto the expansive deck overlooking the beautiful blue water, perfect for grilling, entertaining, or simply enjoying peaceful lake views. Low elevation to 100 ft of swimmable frontage, dock included, plus ample space to add a boat lift. The 35 x 26 utility room/unfinished walkout basement provides excellent opportunity to expand your living space already plumbed for a 2nd bath, additional bedroom, and family/rec. room, along with 26 x 11 garage- storage for a boat, trailer, lake toys, or side-by-side. Easily add a wall and fire barrier to block off the garage. See supplements full a list of included and negotiable items. Located next to a small public boat launch (no parking avail.)—primarily used by neighbors, helps maintain a quiet and peaceful setting. The property also includes a newer storage shed in front for lake equipment and an additional shed in the back for lawn care, etc. Need a bigger garage? Zoning indicates potential to add an additional garage near the home with access driveway off of Small Rd. Outdoor enthusiasts will love the proximity to Gerlach Boat Landing, excellent fishing and full recreation on Nelson Lake, plus direct access to snowmobile and UTV trails right from the property. An excellent opportunity to own a versatile and scenic waterfront home ready for its next chapter!


Listing courtesy of Angelyn Tinucci, Route 63 Realty LLC
Purchase Price
Loan Type
Down Payment
Interest Rate
Estimated Property Taxes
Homeowner's Insurance
HOA Dues
Private Mortgage Insurance
Ask a Question
Your message has been sent.
Oops! that doesn't seem right.
SEND
Sign Up for a Free Monthly Market Report
Never miss out on the latest stats trends and homes in your community.
Get It Now

Property Details

Features

 
 
 
Property Type: Single Family
Status: Active
Year Built: 2001
MLS #: 1600430
Stories: 1.0
Bedrooms: 2
Square Feet: 1,344
Bathrooms (Full): 1
Price Per Square Foot: $391
Bathrooms (Half) : 0
Garage Spaces: 1
Garage: 1
Parking Description: Driveway, Gravel, Garage Door Opener
Sewer Description: Septic Tank
Air Conditioning Type: Central Air
Water: DrilledWell, Private, Well
Heat Type: Forced Air
Basement: Full, Walk-Out Access
Foundation Type: Poured
Construction Description: Vinyl Siding
Days On Market (Continuous): 12
Latest Update: 05/23/2026
List Date: 05/10/2026
Listing Agent ID: ANGIETINUCCI
Listing Office: Route 63 Realty LLC
Listing Office ID: 9388
Data Source: RANWW (NWWMLS)- REALTORS® Association of Northwestern Wisconsin
Appliances: Microwave, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Range Hood
Fireplace Features: One, Wood Burning
Interior Features: Ceiling Fan(s)
Number of Fireplaces: 1
Exterior Features: Dock
Fence: None
Lot Dimensions: 334 x 98 x 344 x 100
Lot Size: 0.7 Acres
View Description: Water
Waterfront: Lake
School District: Hayward Community
Tax Year: 2025
Estimated Taxes: $2,807
City: Hayward
Zip: 54843
County: Sawyer
State: WI

Similar Homes

Listing last updated: 05/23/26

Information provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the NWW MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this site's owner indicate as such. Information provided by seller, listing broker and other parties may not have been verified. Some properties on this web site may have sold and may no longer be available.